|
Wireless Application Service Providers - WASP
Criteria for Assessing a W-ASP
With a market populated with industry leaders, ASPs, and neophyte companies,
choosing a proven W-ASP can be daunting task -- how does one tell them apart?
They all appear to promise the convenience and the freedom from implementing a
wireless system. But do they? Mobileinfo.Com has compiled a set of criteria on which
an enterprise can make an informed decision.
W-ASP Model
Instead of investing in costly infrastructure, involving equipment
purchases, which need to be maintained and upgraded, and in the training and
hiring of staff, the W-ASP model enables the enterprise to rent or, in effect,
subscribe to a complete or partial wireless solution. In most cases, a company
will pay based on a monthly per user/transaction fee, including a percentage of
the costs for the middleware license and maintenance charges, thus eliminating
significant up-front costs. The hosting provider runs either the server, or
server/application combination off-site on its own hardware. In addition, it
would be responsible for maintaining the communications hardware and software
infrastructure.
Typical Cost Implications
According to figures compiled by Broadbeam, a W-ASP, over a three-year period,
it would cost a company approximately $155,000 for the wireless middleware and
maintenance costs for a single device and network, with 200 users, by employing
an in-house approach. Where the same project would cost $105,000 using the W-ASP
model.
Core Hosting Service
There are many companies claiming they are Wireless ASPs, even though they
do not fit. According to our definition, the
core service of any W-ASP is hosting. Over the last twelve months, there have
been many companies offering wireless applications, but of those few offer a
comprehensive hosting service. Many offer, essentially, complementary services,
which may be inadequate to meet the needs of an organization. In most cases, a
hosting service comprise of the following:
-
Network Connectivity
-
24 x 7 365 Real-time monitoring
-
Help desk support
-
Problem detection
-
Diagnostics and resolution
-
Statistical reporting
Wireless ASP’s support centers can often identify potential problems;
maintain all connections to the networks and set up, and maintain and upgrade
all server and hardware. In addition, the W-ASP can monitor traffic and billing,
and create a hybrid of network connectivity to maximize coverage, while
minimizing costs.
Expertise
Essentially, a W-ASP is as good as its skilled professionals. It is essential
that the staff have expertise in wireless technologies from development to
deployment to management. Does the W-ASP specialize in one or two technologies,
such as SMS versus WAP versus Bluetooth? Even though a W-ASP may have the
expertise and experience, does it have the manpower to host a comprehensive
hosting service? Does it have experience in particular industries?
Research shows that relative cost for manpower for a medium-size installation
is about $230,000 to provide
the support in house while a Wireless ASP can provide it for approximately
$145,000. (Source Broadbeam)
End-To-End Solution
Can the W-ASP provide an end-to-end solution that includes wireless network;
wireless data transmission; wireless protocols; end-user devices; wireless
modems; wireless carrier management; customer support, and network management?
In addition, does the infrastructure support multiple networks and devices, with
the security, redundancies, and fault-tolerance necessary to run
mission-critical applications?
Wireless Connectivity
To ensure reliable and continuous service, it is critical that the W-ASP monitor and manage wireless connectivity 24 x 7 x 365. What technologies and
procedures are in place to guarantee a secure operational service, such as
security, fault-tolerance, network monitoring and control, and redundant
connections to the wireless service provider?
Customer Support
Beyond the technical components of the service, equally important is the
manpower needed for implementation, project planning, and technical support. For
instance, one service quite often over looked is a comprehensive training
program that specifically addresses the needs of the end-users. Equally
important is 24 x 7 customer support, especially for larger companies due to the
nature of their business and the work schedules of their mobile workers. Is the
W-ASP’s customer support or help desk manned by qualified workers who can meet
the needs of all users?
Product Fulfillment
Can the W-ASP manage hardware, end-user devices, software, and carrier
relationships?
Best-of-Breed Solution
No one W-ASP can provide an end-to-end or comprehensive wireless solution
without agreements with other vendors. A W-ASP thus will have to have partnership
agreements with other vendors from carriers to wireless handset manufacturers.
It is important, therefore, for a potential customer to be aware of and
understand these agreements in order to assess the quality of technology and
service provided. Ideally, the vendors should have worked together successfully
in the past.
Open Standards
In order to preserve an organization’s IT investment, a W-ASP should be
able to leverage its existing infrastructure while extending it to mobile and
wireless devices. For example, a W-ASP’s wireless server should be able to
provide open enterprise integration into existing corporate systems including
databases, enterprise resource planning systems, and legacy systems.
Scalability
With the plethora of existing wireless devices and the emergence of next
generation devices, a W-ASP should be able to handle the expansion of new users
and remote offices. For example, organizations often add new networks for
coverage in newly deployed regions. While wireless middleware can assist in
this, hosting ensures that new network deployments involve minimal up-front
costs and no down time.
Security
When an organization decides to extend critical applications to new devices,
networks, and protocols, new security issues must be addressed. Does the W-ASP provide authentication and authorization as well as data encryption? Can the
W-ASP integrate wireless-specific security support with existing security
infrastructure such as firewalls, PKI technology, and VPNs.
Opt-Out Feature in Your Agreements With a W-ASP
W-ASP agreements should not tie you down with a single vendor or on a specific
business arrangement for a long time. In view of the nascent nature of the
market, we advise opt-out option after one year, then three and five year
period. In case of opt-out, you should have a pre-determined cost of
repatriation of application software infrastructure - just like a car lease.
Time to Market
A marketing incentive used by all W-ASPs is the promise of freedom from the
hassles of developing and deploying a wireless system. To a great extent,
hosting with a W-ASP can eliminate most problems and time-consuming factors, such
as establishing connections to wireless carriers. In most cases, a customer can
expect network deployments to have minimal or absolutely no effect on its
day-to-day operations. Companies that have worked along side their W-ASP, such as
putting the necessary provisions in place, have reported experiencing
"close to hassle free transitions."
Criteria For Evaluating Wireless ASPs
-
Vendor's wireless systems integration expertise
-
Vendor's mobile application development expertise
-
Ownership of infrastructure used to operate the service - if it is through
a third party ISP, what value do they add and is this significant as
compared to going directly to the ISP.
-
Service level agreement that specifies quality of service
-
Number of customers it has
-
Vendor survival index - number of years in business and adequately funded
business model
-
References of current set of customers
-
Flexibility of contracts - opt-out feature
-
Transfer ownership of application software customization
|